Try Amazon Prime free for 30 days
Fast free delivery on heavy items, plus Prime Video, Prime Music and member-only deal prices.
The furnace repair is booked for next week, the back bedroom feels like a walk-in cooler, and someone has started wearing a ski hat to dinner. Direct vent gas heaters fix that kind of cold room by pulling combustion air from outside and sending exhaust back out through the wall. After comparing 6 models, the Comfort Glow 25,000 BTU Natural Gas Wall Heater leads with 25,000 BTU, a rating for up to 750 square feet and an adjustable thermostat. The Rinnai 21,500 BTU Natural Gas Heater is our alternative pick, with 21,500 BTU and a programmable thermostat.
Pros
- 25,000 BTU output heats up to 750 sq. ft.
- Thermostatic heat control for adjustable warmth
- No electricity needed for operation
- Direct vent kit included for 4.5 to 10 inch walls
- Sealed burn system with safety pilot and regulator
Cons
- Requires natural gas and direct vent wall installation
- 60 lb weight may make wall mounting harder
- Heats up to 750 sq. ft., not for larger spaces
Pros
- 21,500 BTU natural gas wall furnace
- Programmable thermostat for set temperatures
- Cool-to-the-touch cabinet and self-diagnostics
- Compact 10.1 x 29.9 x 22.9 inch wall design
- 10-year heat exchanger warranty
Cons
- 67 lb weight may make installation harder
- Requires natural gas and direct vent setup
- Heating area is not specified
Pros
- 11,000 BTUs heats spaces up to 375 sq ft
- Operates without electricity for outages or off-grid use
- Direct-vent sealed burn system vents exhaust outdoors
- AA battery manual ignition, battery included
- Includes mounting bracket and vent kit
Cons
- Limited to spaces up to 375 sq ft
- Uses natural gas and requires direct-vent installation
- Optional blower is sold separately and requires electricity
Pros
- 21,500 BTU natural gas wall furnace
- Programmable thermostat for set temperatures
- Cool-to-the-touch cabinet for family areas
- Self-diagnostic electronics for safer operation
- 10-year heat exchanger warranty
Cons
- Requires natural gas and direct vent installation
- 67 lb weight is not portable
- Wall-mounted design limits placement flexibility
Pros
- 38,400 BTU natural gas heat output
- Direct vent wall furnace for indoor spaces
- Programmable thermostat for set temperatures
- Cool-to-the-touch cabinet for safer contact
- 10-year heat exchanger warranty
Cons
- Requires natural gas and direct vent wall installation
- 108 lb weight may make installation harder
- Fixed wall design is not portable
Pros
- 35,000 Btu size
- 24,500 BTU output
- Direct-vent wall furnace design
- 37 x 11.5 x 27.75 inch listed dimensions
- Beige powder-coated finish
Cons
- Requires liquid propane fuel
- Heating area is not specified
- Thermostat details are not listed
What We Looked For in a Gas Heater for Cold Rooms and Power Outages
A gas heater burns fuel inside your living space, so heat output only matters if the venting, ignition and shut-offs are right. We weighed each model on these points in this order.
- Heat output and coverage: Among our picks, input ratings run from 11,000 to 38,400 BTU. The Comfort Glow 25,000 BTU Natural Gas Wall Heater puts out 25,000 BTU and is rated for up to 750 square feet, double the 375 square foot rating of our smallest pick. That is enough for an open living area, a small cabin or a two-car garage conversion. Watch input versus output, too: our one propane pick lists 35,000 BTU input but 24,500 BTU of actual output.
- Indoor rating and oxygen depletion protection: According to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, unvented gas heaters should have an oxygen depletion sensor that shuts the heater off if oxygen drops too low. All 6 of our picks avoid that risk with a sealed burn system that draws air from outside instead of from the room. Two of our picks are approved for mobile homes, and one is also approved for bedrooms and bathrooms.
- Ventilation and carbon monoxide precautions: Direct venting sends exhaust outdoors through the wall, so no chimney is needed. Two of our picks ship with a full vent kit, and one of those fits walls from 4.5 to 10 inches thick. The CDC still recommends a battery-operated carbon monoxide detector, and federal fire agencies say to keep anything that can burn at least 3 feet away.
- Fuel type and supply: Five of our 6 picks burn natural gas and 1 burns liquid propane. None of them has an onboard tank, so run time depends on your gas line or propane supply rather than a refill schedule. The CDC advises using only the fuel a heater is designed for, so match the model to the fuel you already have.
- Ignition and safety shut-offs: The Ashley DVAG11N lights with a single AA battery and runs without household electricity, which keeps 11,000 BTU flowing during a power outage. Once the pilot is lit, its internal thermostat handles the rest for rooms up to 375 square feet. Our top pick also needs no electricity and adds a safety pilot that stops gas flow if the flame goes out.
- Size and weight: These are wall-mounted units, not carry-around heaters, so weight matters mostly on install day. The Rinnai EX22DTN weighs about 67 pounds for 21,500 BTU, roughly 27 pounds more than our lightest pick. In return it brings a cool-to-the-touch cabinet and self-diagnostic electronics, plus a 10-year heat exchanger warranty.
We left out central furnaces and whole-house systems because they need professional installation and ductwork planning beyond a single room. Water heaters and heated blankets do a different job, and outdoor-only patio heaters are not rated for enclosed spaces. If none of our 6 picks fits your room, the next group covers smaller and fuel-swapped versions.
Other Gas Heaters Worth Considering
These are other gas heaters we looked at but did not put on our main list.
Want our top pick’s design in a size down? The Comfort Glow 17,000 BTU Natural Gas Wall Heater is rated for up to 500 square feet and weighs about 43 pounds. That is 8,000 BTU less than our top pick, which suits a single bedroom or den better than an open floor plan.
Homes on propane rather than a natural gas line can look at the Comfort Glow 25,000 BTU Propane Wall Heater. It matches our top pick at 25,000 BTU, 750 square feet and about 60 pounds, with a different design and feature mix for that fuel.
If your space falls between our two smallest picks, the Ashley DVAG17N lands in the middle at 17,000 BTU for up to 570 square feet. It keeps an adjustable thermostat and weighs about 54.4 pounds, but it gives up 8,000 BTU against our top pick.
And if all you need is a little warmth in a small room, the Ashley 8,000 BTU Propane Wall Heater covers up to 300 square feet. At about 17 pounds it is the lightest heater here, though its 8,000 BTU is roughly a third of our top pick’s output.
FAQs
Do direct vent gas heaters need an oxygen depletion sensor?
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission calls for an oxygen depletion sensor on unvented gas heaters, since those burn room air. Direct vent models use a sealed burn system that pulls air from outside and vents exhaust outdoors, so room oxygen is not consumed the same way. A battery-operated carbon monoxide detector is still a smart addition, as the CDC recommends.
Will a direct vent gas heater work during a power outage?
Several can. Among our picks, two run without household electricity, one of them using a single AA battery for ignition. Optional blowers on some models do need power, so the heater will still warm the room in an outage but without forced air circulation.
How many BTU do I need for my room?
Use the square footage rating as your starting point. Our picks range from 11,000 BTU for up to 375 square feet to 25,000 BTU for up to 750 square feet, and the largest model reaches 38,400 BTU. Drafty cabins and garages with thin walls may need the upper end of that range.
How far should furniture be from a wall-mounted gas heater?
The U.S. Fire Administration, the CDC and the CPSC all advise keeping anything that can burn at least 3 feet away. That includes drapes, bedding and furniture. The U.S. Fire Administration also notes that heating fires are the second leading cause of home fires.
Sources
- CPSC Offers Tips to Prevent Home Fires From Space Heaters, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Fire-safety tips and required safety features for space heaters.
- Safety Guidelines: During & After a Winter Storm, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Winter heating safety for space heaters, kerosene heaters and carbon monoxide.
- Heating Fire Safety, U.S. Fire Administration. Home heating fire statistics and prevention messages.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!